Sappho
Who cares about story line... Johnny Depp is hot!!!

deefrost
Probably Pirates one. Pirates has a good story line, but really sets up Pirates 3. My favorite Pirate is Captain Morgan with a slice of orange

Pirate 4 Life
the first one had more of a complete and less complicated story line my fav. movie is pirates of the caribbean: the curse of the black pearl

marsminute
The first one had a much, much, much better storyline. In fact, everything about the first movie was better! Although I think Keira looked even better in the 2nd movie!

i_love_dogs007
I think Pirates 1 does...but i agree with the first girl. johnny depp is freakin HOT!

wonderfull
number 1

Eva
the second one was just furthering the plot established by the first movie. But Depp and Bloom are sooo incredibly gorgeous that no plot is necessary!!!

STUPID IN CANADA
Pirates One. Love Capt Barbossa

matrix15sam
I LOVED THEM BOTH AND OF COURSE THE BEST PIRATE IS CAPTAIN JACK SPARROW 'that is by far the best pirate i have ever seen' 'so it would seem'