Jeff- BA, MMin, follows Jesus
No. But I do give a thumbs down if their answer has no basis or is attacking. Occasionally I have even given thumbs up to Atheists...if they are at least respectful or fair.

supertop
No; my thumbs up or down are based solely on the content of the answer.

yesmar
Nope, I never give a thumbs down. I will give a thumbs up if the answer is interesting or intelligent though. Thanks for asking.

The Truth Fairy 2
I've given a few theists thumbs up because they backed up their claims well, and claimed they didn't know everything they had faith and believed. I hate it when people claim they KNOW something when they don't.

Kenshin Himura
No.

lainiebsky
Not that I recall. If there's a well-written answer that I think is totally wrong I just don't rate it. Same thing if there's a rude answer on the side that I agree with.

Ms. Taurus
Generally no. Thumbs up go to the answers I really like (or enjoy). Down only to those who are hateful, judging, toll-like, or the "omg of course my views are right, why can't they get it through their heads" types.

Angel
No, that's silly. I vote based on their intelligence or lack of.

zeitgeist
Good question! If the "thumbs down" is not used, then what is it's purpose? I occasionally use it for lame answers, where the only objective is to launch an attack against another. Usually, I just ignore them.

The Tsunami Swami
No. I only give thumbs down if they're slandering other groups or members for no apparent reason, or the person in question is an obvious troll.

Fern
I don't give thumbs down for a person's belief systems. That is part of who they are and I don't condone putting someone down when they are simply being who they are. I have been known to thumbs down people who are rude, ignorant, or intolerant of others. Those are things I just think are wrong. Its possible to answer a question and be civil to the asker even if you don't believe what they are saying. If an answer is rash and misinformed I will thumbs down from time to time. If a person is honest and courteous then there is no reason to thumbs down that type of honesty.

The Walkin' Dude
Nah. I thumb down the ones I find stupid. Smart ones up and funny ones too.

Zero Cool
No, I have not. An unbiased opinion is the best way to judge the work of others. I try my best to remain unbiased.

Darwin
I give a thumbs-up when the respondent sufficiently answers the question.